The other night, I stumbled. Not with my eating or my exercise – though neither of those were perfect – but with my mindset.
It started with me “stumbling” onto a picture of myself. I was actually looking for pictures of myself, for a particular reason, but I wanted good ones. I didn’t find any of those. For one thing, I have evidently made a practice over the past ten years of being extremely unavailable to the camera. I sort of knew that, but…it’s still sobering to realize just how good I had gotten at it.
Still, I did find a few pictures. And I hated them all. But it wasn’t until I found this one, from about four years ago, that I absolutely cringed – and I will warn you now, it’s not pretty. Brace yourself:
What I found appalling is not the way I looked – I was prepared for that – but the fact that I very clearly remember this day, and what I remember seeing in the mirror bears no resemblance whatsoever to what I see in this picture. I had no idea. This is, for me, a very clear illustration of the fact that my body image is completely out of touch with reality. I am not capable of judging my own appearance. (And of course people aren’t telling me the truth – I mean, who tells someone they love, “Oh, you look terrible, don’t go out like that!” Come on. And if they had, or did, I’d be pissed.)
So that scares me. It upsets me, and it scares me. And more so because I found another picture – I can’t put this one in because it’s on another computer and I can’t get to it right now, but I’ll add it later if I get a chance – from a few weeks ago that still looks pretty bad, and not at all the way I remember thinking I looked. 60 pounds and a completely different lifestyle and mindset later, and I am still not seeing myself the way I really look. Again, that scares me.
How am I really going to know when I’m where I need to be? I have said before that my real, true goal is to be able to take a picture of myself and like what I see. I am not even close to that, clearly – at least, not a picture from the neck down, and even taking one from the neck up requires intricate planning and positioning. And I’ve been fighting depression for two days because of this…
And that’s the stumble. Because I know very well that beating myself up and giving in to despair and self-loathing are the very things that will make me fail. They are the very things that can and will derail me, if I let them. I cannot do this to myself. I cannot mire myself in disgust at my own delusions and fear that I am and will always be disgustingly fat, even when I think I’m not. We all know what lies down that road, and it’s nothing good. It’s nothing I want. I must, and I will, reject that path.
When I realized I was starting that downward spiral that I know from experience would eventually lead to depression-fueled binge eating and lethargy (about ten seconds after I first saw the picture), my mind immediately tossed up a post from GrumpyChair. She’s talking about her six-week checkup after giving birth and discovering she hadn’t lost nearly as much weight as she felt she should. The comment that really stuck in my head was, “This did not make me want to go home and pop in an aerobics tape and eat salad.” (There are other posts in the same timeframe that talk about pictures, and one in particular about how she unconsciously edited herself out of the photographic history of her family. That one hit home, too.)
Why do we do this to ourselves? Why is it that, when we are faced with a discouraging truth about our weight, our appearance, our health – our immediate reaction is to binge? To go comfort ourselves with the very things that made us this way? I know the scientific reasons…I understand how that works…but it’s not okay, and from a psychological and intellectual standpoint it’s insane. And for me, the bottom line is that I have got to forgive myself for what I became, and I have to do it now. I have got to stop sinking into the weeping-and-wailing frame of mind and remember that while I may not be where I want to be, I have made enormous progress, and I have every right to be proud and happy about that progress. I do need to stop deluding myself that I’m done…but that doesn’t mean I have to feel as though I’m back where I started. Because I’m not.
I know that I look better. My body image isn’t quite that skewed. I know I look decent a lot of the time, and sometimes I even look pretty damned hot, based on other people’s reactions. I just need to accept that my own glances in the mirror are not going to give me honest information.
I knew this at one time. I started this process out by taking – or actually, having DH take – regular progress photos so I could see where I was headed and how I was doing at getting there. I’ve stopped doing that, and I think that was a mistake. (Evidently, this is one of those lessons that takes several repetitions for me to learn.) I think had I kept it up, I wouldn’t be facing this dark epiphany again right now.
So that’s something we’re going to start back up immediately.
If you’ve made it this far, I imagine you are despairing of ever reaching the “wisdom” part of the post. The truth is, you already touched on it. Forgiveness. We are taught to try to be the best people we can be. We are taught to try to do things right and to make as few mistakes as possible. And there’s wisdom in that, of course, because obviously life is better when you get things right and don’t screw things up for yourself any more than necessary. But what we aren’t taught is that it is impossible to never make mistakes – we are only human, and we are all going to screw up, a lot. We will fail. We will be, at some point in our lives, nearly all of the things we despise the most. Hopefully, we will catch ourselves before that gets out of hand, but we can’t prevent it entirely, and if we try, we destroy our own joy in life. One of my favorite lines from a song is from “Unwritten” by Natasha Bedingfield: “We are conditioned/to not make mistakes/but I can’t live that way…” And neither can anyone else, though we kill ourselves trying.
And we aren’t taught that when these mistakes or stupid decisions happen, it doesn’t make us bad or worthless or stupid or evil or whatever adjective you want to use in your personal self-castigation. It makes us normal, and human. It’s how we learn. Nor are we taught that when it happens, the right thing, the good thing, the personally beneficial thing to do is to take the lesson and then forgive. We do hear a little bit about forgiveness of others…but rarely do we hear much about forgiving ourselves.
That’s what passes for wisdom from me today. Forgive yourself. Whatever you did or didn’t do or said or didn’t say or forgot or neglected or just screwed up…it’s not the end of the world. Even if the consequences are grim, you really aren’t the Dark One for having done it. You are no worse a person than anyone else for having made that mistake, and mistakes are not all bad if they are turned into lessons learned. So figure out where you went wrong, and (if you can) why, and then forgive yourself. You’re only human. And as bad as it is for you to hold a grudge against someone else, it’s a million times worse to hold one against you. So forgive yourself. And I’ll do the same.
(I originally said “try to do the same” but then my mindset was saved by, of all people, Yoda. “Do, or do not. There is no try.” God, I love that quote.)
So go, and do!

you sell yourself short.
no, not just the outside you. the look of you. the photo of you. but in the “if youve made it this far” you
I love reading all the way through your posts.
hitting the end.
digesting the nugget & returning to the beginning again to see how it all fell into place.
were you a seinfeld fan?
like that. when you reach the “it all pulls together” end it makes (made? made just me? who can say) you wanna return to the beginning and revisit with the knowledge of the end in mind.
xo xo,
Miz.
One of my greatest life lessons was given to me by a manager at work, after I had screwed up royally and made extra work for a lot of folks. He said, “The only people not making mistakes are the ones not doing anything.” (I love that quote and have the opportunity to use it on myself frequently.*g*)
I do understand the body image thing, my friend. Unfortunately, I have found no solutions for myself, so I have no suggestions for making it all just go away. (Wouldn’t that be wonderful?) I think you’re on the right track, though, in focusing on the New! Improved! version of you–inside and out–rather than the previous model. (Although I have to say that I thought the photo was great. You look relaxed and happy.)
I feel your pain, sister.
I’d like to link to your blog from mine… I’m trying to compile a list of other weight loss blogs to help me motivate myself. Would that be ok?
Hang in there, and stick with it.
I love reading and catching up with your posts. You are so thoughtful and such a great writer. This post had so many things for me to think about….
Why is it we think we managed to fool ourselves into looking thinner when we are at our heaviest and yet when we lose weight, we see more and more imperfections?
Forgiving ourselves is way harder than forgiving others which in itself is a hard thing to do at times.
BTW, I think I am a cosmic teenager. Maybe with luck, I can be Eloise at the Plaza though.
Thanks for several really good thought-provoking posts.
I agree with cammy… I think you’re seeing something in that photo that’s not there.
Wow, I mean, even then, look at you! You look happy, and you’ve got some great skin, and a beautiful smile and very nice legs…
I think there’s some perspective thing with the mirror and the camera. I even take my own pictures IN the mirror and what I see in the mirror and what I see in the photo of the exact SAME instant aren’t the same. Maybe we all look better when we’re moving, that something about capturing a flat, static picture automatically makes everyone and everything a little bit less than it was when it was moving.
Body image is an issue that we all struggle with as we try to lose weight. Some days I wake up and look in the mirror and think “man, losing that 60 pounds makes me look pretty good” and other days I think “what a disgusting mess, look at that abdominal fat.” But I wonder how much of our perception is based on the mood we are already in. I know that the days I think I look pretty good tend to be the ones where I am already in a good mood. Just something to think about.
Now, a few words about my perceptions of you.
First, when I think about Valerie, the first things that come to my mind are what a great inspiration you have been for me in my own weight loss journey, what a terrific co-worker you are, and what a phenomenal friend you have been to me. [And before you bust my chops for not recognizing your hotness, its just that the more substantive and important things come to mind first. ; )].
Second, despite the emphasis that society (particularly the media) places on physical appearance above all else, many, if not most, people’s perceptions of other people’s looks are influenced by far more than mere physical appearance. And I will give you two examples specifically related to you, but which should be lessons to all of us (including me).
Way back before you started your weight loss efforts and before we knew each other real well, I took particular note of you because of your friendliness, vibrant and outgoing personality, and confidence. Those characteristics certainly influenced my perceptions of you and made me want to get to know you.
Now, go back up and look at your picture again. What I noticed first was the smile. You genuinely appear to be having a good time. You look like a fun loving person. You look like someone I would want to get to know (and was right about that time). You look like someone that would be fun to talk to and hang out with. That’s how you appear to me in the picture. Nothing more, nothing less.
Third, if you need someone to be honest with you about your appearance – you know I have been in the past and will be happy to do so again in the future. That’s one of the great things about our friendship – we aren’t afraid to say or hear the hard things because we both just want what is best for the other. Plus, I have the added advantage over your DH in that I don’t have to go home with you at night, go to sleep…, and wonder if I am going to wake up. LOL.
My girlfriends here in NYC have a pact…we go shopping together and if something looks bad on us, we tell the truth to the other. It’s not hurtful, just nah, pick something else, that outfit doesn’t really work for you. I have to say I really appreciate this and the fact that they’re willing to speak up…it also taught me what styles actually look good on my body type, even though it constantly changes…I still am and will always be a curvy girl.
I saw the photo and didn’t recognize you…however, I must say I’m awfully jealous of your rocking tan inwhich I’m rather incapable of achieving…and the fact that even though your Ms. Chubby McChubster in that pic, you still look pretty darn good and you’re bathing suit is actually appropriate in covering/showing the right parts. I don’t have many pics of myself in my McChubster phase, however, when I do see the few that do exist, I’m always amazed…In person, I always see myself as the same whether heavy or thin and only pictures really show the truth (sadly).
I’ve found that looking at those old, fat pics and videos of myself send me spiralling into comfort food and depression as you mentioned above and so I use an opposite action to off-set it. I find pics in magazines and catalogs that inspire me to keep working. Like the bikini spread in a fitness magazine, or as sappy and conformist as this is, the Victoria’s Secret catalog…seeing those girls look great in lingerie and bikinis always remind me what I’m working towards. Will I ever look like them?…I’ll never know unless I try…or as you quoted…DO…do the work! Find the pics that inspire you.
So do the work Val…put the positive pics up on the fridge, on the cabinets where food is stored, next to your work-out equipment and videos…in a place where those inspiration pics are the first thing you see in the morning and when you come home at night…they will encourage you to keep doing the work…what you’re working towards. And put away the old pics that depress you and don’t pull them out again until you’ve reached a certain goal that you’ve set for yourself.
Love ya girl, & Stay Strong,
-Bex
Wow, you’ve certainly touched a nerve with this reader. Not only are you a good writer, but you’ve managed to express what I have a hard time explaining, and even a harder time understanding…body image.
I’m interested to know if anybody has published research about this strange phenomenon that seems so common among us?
[...] Along with NFL, the Diet Book blogs on a similar vein with Wednesday Wisdom: Forgiveness. [...]
Frankly, when I saw this, I thought you looked beautiful because you look so happy!
Forgiveness is the greatest gift, yet it’s one we seldom give to ourselves, but one that we need to give more often (to everyone really).
I think the book title should be “Wednesday Wisdom”… it works!
(the first book I mean… the second, and third, and 37th can be up to you
).
[...] Along with NFL, the Diet Book blogs on a similar vein with Wednesday Wisdom: Forgiveness. [...]